Selecting Microcontrollers for Music

Kevin

May 7

I was browsing some of the newer ATtiny chips the other day and started to make a note of some of their properties and it made me realise I actually have quite a few different microcontrollers at my disposal and many more I could be having a look at.

But having committed to not attempting to get hold of every variant of every device to put a MIDI interface on it, I thought it would still be worth a post summarising some of the features to make selecting them in the future a little easier.

There are many comparison charts and tables online, but this is my own summary of the things that are important to me right now in terms of using them for musical purposes.

Note: I think the data is correct at the time of writing. Feel free to let me know of any mistakes. Also feel free to let me know what microcontrollers you use for music, and why, in the comments.

8-bit Microcontrollers

MCU	Freq	PWR	GPIO	ADC	PWM	DAC	Comms	RAM	Flash
ATmega328P	16MHz	2.7-5.5V	23	6/8	6	0	UART, I2C, SPI	2K	32K
ATmega32U4	16MHz	2.7-5.5V	26	12	8	0	UART, I2C, SPI, USB	2.5K	32K
ATtiny85	8/20MHz	2.7-5.5V	6	4	6	0	USI	512	8K
ATtiny88	12MHz	2.7-5.5V	28	6	2	0	I2C, SPI	512	8K
ATtiny21(2\|4) ATtiny41(2\|4\|6)	20MHz	1.8-5.5V	6\|12 6\|12\|18	6\|10 6\|10\|12	6	1	UART, I2C, SPI	128 256	2K 4K

32-bit Microcontrollers

MCU	Freq	PWR	GPIO	ADC	PWM	DAC	Comms	RAM	Flash
SAMD21 (M0+)	48MHz	1.6-3.6V	30/38	14	30?	1	SERCOM, I2S, USB	4-32K	32-256K
SAMD51 (M4)	120MHz	1.6-3.6V	51	32	37?	1	SERCOM, I2S, USB	128-256	256-1024K
RP2040 (2xM0+)	133MHz	3.3V	30	4	11	0	UART, I2C, SPI, USB, PIO	264K	external
ESP32 (LX6)	160MHz	3.0-3.6V	34	18	16	2	UART, I2C, SPI, I2S, Wi-Fi, BT	0-2M	0-4M
ESP32-S2 (LX7)	240MHz	2.8-3.6V	43	20	8	0	UART, I2C, SPI, I2S, Wi-Fi	0-2M	0-2-4M
ESP32-S3 (2xLX7)	240MHz	3.0-3.6V	45	20	8	0	UART, I2C, SPI, I2S, Wi-Fi, BT	0-2-8-16M	0-4-8M
ESP32-A1S (2xLX6)	240MHx	3.0-3.6V	14	?	?	2	UART, I2C, SPI, I2S	520K+4M	0?

Points of Note

The ATmega and ATtiny devices are all 8-bit AVR architecture and might be either 3V3 or 5V operation depending on the device. Whereas the others are all 32-bit, 3V3 operation, and either ARM or Tensilica Xtensa architectures.
The SAMD51, ESP32 and ESP32-S3 are all interesting as they include a floating point unit, which might be useful if I get into requiring mathematical synthesis.
ATtiny2xx, ATtiny4xx, SAMD21, SAMD51, ESP32 all include a DAC which would be really useful for generating control voltages.
ATmega32U4, SAMD21, SAMD51, RP2040 all support USB directly.
The last one is an interesting device. The ESP32-A1S is a single module that includes an ESP32 and a CODEC module. More recent versions use the ES8388 and support two audio in/out channels. There is an Espressif Audio Development Framework for use with all ESP32-based devices.

Other MCUs of possible interest might include some of the newer RISC-V devices (e.g. ESP32-C3), the STM32 device range (the higher performing devices include floating point support, for example), the Teensy boards (which have a strong following for audio applications), and even running with the broadcom devices used on the various Raspberry Pis in "bare metal" mode.

A key tradeoff already would be choosing between a more powerful, probably 32-bit, 3V3 logic devices or a less capable 5V device.

Development Boards

I'm unlikely to be working with a microcontroller directly though, given my own level of knowledge, so I'm probably going to be looking at some kind of development board.

The following could all be possibilities if I'm happy running at 3V3.

Note, many of the form-factors, e.g. Adafruit's QT Py or Feather, support most of the architectures - but not all are listed - just those I have or might consider. I've also added in some other boards that I know are often used (or shout about being used) for audio applications.

Prices are approximate at time of writing (Feb 2024).

Board	MCU	Arch	Speed	RAM/Flash	GPIO	ADC	PWM	I2S	DAC	Cost
RPi Pico	RP2040	2xM0+	133MHz	264K/2M	27	3	16	PIO	0	£4
XIAO	SAMD21	M0+	48MHz	32K/256K	14	11	11	1	1	£6
XIAO	RP2040	2xM0+	133MHz	264K/2M	11	4	11	PIO	0	£6
XIAO	ESP32-S3	2xLX7	240MHz	8M/8M	11	9	11	1	0	£8
XIAO	ESP32-C3	RISC-V	160MHz	4K/4M	11	4	11		0	£6
QT Py	SAMD21	M0+	48MHz	32K/256K	11	9	9	1	1	£9
QT Py	RP2040	2xM0+	125MHz	264K/8M	13	4	13	PIO	0	£10
QT Py	ESP32-S3	2xLX7	240MHz	512K+2M/4M	13	10	13	1	0	£15
Trinket	SAMD21	M0+	48MHz	32K/256K	5	5	2	1	1	£9
ItsyBitsy	SAMD21	M0+	48MHz	32K/256K	23	11	13	1	1	£12
ItsyBitsy	SAMD51	M4	120MHz	192K/512K+2M	23	7	18	1	2	£15
Feather	SAMD21	M0+	48MHz	32K/256K	20	6	20	1	1	£19
Feather	SAMD51	M4	120MHz	192K/512K+2M	21	6	16	1	2	£23
Feather	RP2040	2xM0+	125MHz	264K/8M	21	4	16	PIO	0	£12
Feather	ESP32-S3	2xLX7	240MHz	2M/4M	21	6	21	1	0	£17
BananaPicoW	ESP32-S3	2xLX7	240MHz	512K/2M+8M	27	18	8	1	0	£4
WROOM32	ESP32	2xLX6	<240MHz	500K/448K+4M	34	15	25	1	2	£3
Teensy 3.6	MK66FX1	M4F	180MHz	256K/1M	64	25	22	1	2	N/A
Teensy 4.0	IMXRT1062	M7	600MHz	1M/2M	40	14	31	2	0	£26
Teensy 4.1	IMXRT1062	M7	600MHz	1M/8M	55	18	35	2	0	£30
Arduino MKR Zero	SAMD21	M0+	48MHz	32K/256K	22	7	13	1	1	£30
Arduino Giga R1	STM32H747X	M7 M4	480MHz 240MHz	1M/2M	76	14	13	?	2	£70

It is interesting to note which boards support a DAC and which support I2S, both very useful for audio applications and the number of ADCs is relevant too.

Boards specifically designed for audio processing, which I've no direct experience of, include:

Pico ADK - A RP2040 based "audio development kit" with 8 ADCs and SPI DAC.
Daisy Seed - an ARM Cortex-M7 with audio IO designed for DSP and audio applications (£35)
Bela and Bela Mini - designed for use with Beaglebone for real-time, low-latency audio processing (~£130-£160).